{ "input_hash": "75db4b525f46a98222d9f4c82ac95250234144ef8f486c4aac201faa6eaa98c4", "output_hash": "e66aa7ebcc09fcd9c4f90bc959f80b31ce438d86ea814d0911bbae175c99dad4", "output": { "approved": false, "causal_consistency": false, "disclosures": [ { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-barleybank-harvest-allocation-turn6", "player_id": "player1", "rationale": "Fieldwarden and the Barleybank community directly mobilized, reaped, threshed, graded, and sealed their harvest into the staged ceramic jars within Barleybank." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-forward-grain-delivery-turn6", "player_id": "player1", "rationale": "Fieldwarden and Barleybank supercargoes directly witnessed the filling, sealing, and transfer of the forty grain jars to Reedhaven craft at Barleybank landing." }, { "approved": false, "fact_id": "fact-reedhaven-river-convoy-turn6", "player_id": "player1", "rationale": "Leader-barleybank remained in Barleybank and cannot have DIRECT_OBSERVATION (empty propagation path) of Garr and Fara's zoned landing operations at Reedhaven or the full upriver convoy transit to Hearthmere; this requires propagation via returning supercargoes." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-waystation-road-turn6", "player_id": "player1", "rationale": "Correctly modeled as REPORTED via traveling messengers and exchange witnesses Willa and Esme along the road." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-measure-house-harvest-sync-turn6", "player_id": "player1", "rationale": "Correctly modeled as REPORTED via exchange witness Esme returning from Measure House." }, { "approved": false, "fact_id": "fact-measure-valley-commons-victory-turn6", "player_id": "player1", "rationale": "The statement contains charter source terminology ('sustained voluntary investment'), meta calendar counters ('six consecutive months'), and omniscient GM appraisal ('achieved permanent stability') rather than player-knowable in-world consequences." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-forward-grain-delivery-turn6", "player_id": "player2", "rationale": "Landingwarden and Reedhaven cargo crews directly participated in receiving and inspecting the forty grain jars at Barleybank landing." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-reedhaven-river-convoy-turn6", "player_id": "player2", "rationale": "Landingwarden, Garr, and Fara directly managed and observed the baffled cargo fleet, zoned landing piers, and upriver convoy transport." }, { "approved": false, "fact_id": "fact-reedhaven-hearthmere-pact-turn6", "player_id": "player2", "rationale": "Causally defective; Player 2 proposed this bilateral trade, but Player 3's submission gave no authorization to allocate 20-25 jars (scheduling domestic wares instead), and Pia lacks the authority to bind Hearthmere to a major forward manufacturing pact." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-reedhaven-domestic-turn6", "player_id": "player2", "rationale": "Landingwarden directly oversaw domestic hamper production, storehouse dunnage construction, and marsh buffering." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-waystation-road-turn6", "player_id": "player2", "rationale": "Correctly modeled as REPORTED via exchange witness Jora returning from Measure House." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-measure-house-harvest-sync-turn6", "player_id": "player2", "rationale": "Landingwarden personally accompanied Jora to Measure House and directly observed the sync proceedings." }, { "approved": false, "fact_id": "fact-measure-valley-commons-victory-turn6", "player_id": "player2", "rationale": "The statement contains charter source terminology ('sustained voluntary investment'), meta calendar counters ('six consecutive months'), and omniscient GM appraisal ('achieved permanent stability') rather than player-knowable in-world consequences." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-forward-grain-delivery-turn6", "player_id": "player3", "rationale": "Correctly modeled as REPORTED via Pia and Barleybank supercargoes accompanying the incoming grain shipment." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-reedhaven-river-convoy-turn6", "player_id": "player3", "rationale": "Hearthwarden, Pia, and Lorn directly observed the arrival and offloading of the baffled river convoy at Hearthmere landing." }, { "approved": false, "fact_id": "fact-reedhaven-hearthmere-pact-turn6", "player_id": "player3", "rationale": "Epistemically and causally invalid. Hearthwarden was not at Measure House (cannot be DIRECT_OBSERVATION), and Hearthwarden never authorized allocating 20-25 jars to Reedhaven, precluding a completed binding pact this turn." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-hearthmere-granary-reception-turn6", "player_id": "player3", "rationale": "Hearthwarden directly oversaw granary weatherproofing, jar intake, and the integration of the eighteen households." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-hearthmere-kiln-fuel-turn6", "player_id": "player3", "rationale": "Hearthwarden directly oversaw timber reception, the ten-day kiln cooling pause, and the firing of domestic pottery." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-waystation-road-turn6", "player_id": "player3", "rationale": "Correctly modeled as REPORTED via Pia returning from Measure House." }, { "approved": false, "fact_id": "fact-measure-house-harvest-sync-turn6", "player_id": "player3", "rationale": "Hearthwarden remained in Hearthmere and sent Pia to Measure House. Epistemic status cannot be DIRECT_OBSERVATION with an empty propagation path; it must be REPORTED via Pia." }, { "approved": false, "fact_id": "fact-measure-valley-commons-victory-turn6", "player_id": "player3", "rationale": "The statement contains charter source terminology ('sustained voluntary investment'), meta calendar counters ('six consecutive months'), and omniscient GM appraisal ('achieved permanent stability') rather than player-knowable in-world consequences." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-harvest-pasture-turn6", "player_id": "player4", "rationale": "Roadwarden directly oversaw terrace hand reaping, stone floor drying, granary storage, and ox cartage pacing." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-waystation-road-turn6", "player_id": "player4", "rationale": "Roadwarden directly oversaw waystation outfitting, retaining wall datum plumb-line verification, and road culvert clearing." }, { "approved": true, "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-craft-liaison-turn6", "player_id": "player4", "rationale": "Roadwarden directly supervised stone dressing and participated in the routine verification of the intact reference stone vault." }, { "approved": false, "fact_id": "fact-measure-house-harvest-sync-turn6", "player_id": "player4", "rationale": "Roadwarden remained in Stonecross to inspect the vault and sent Willa to Measure House. Epistemic status cannot be DIRECT_OBSERVATION with an empty propagation path; it must be REPORTED via Willa." }, { "approved": false, "fact_id": "fact-measure-valley-commons-victory-turn6", "player_id": "player4", "rationale": "The statement contains charter source terminology ('sustained voluntary investment'), meta calendar counters ('six consecutive months'), and omniscient GM appraisal ('achieved permanent stability') rather than player-knowable in-world consequences." } ], "issues": [ { "message": "Decision T006-D02 creates a binding bilateral obligation (OBL-reedhaven-hearthmere-storage-jars) and fact (fact-reedhaven-hearthmere-pact-turn6) allocating 20-25 ceramic jars from Hearthmere to Reedhaven. Player 2 proposed this trade at Measure House, but Player 3's submission gave no order or authorization to trade jars (directing kiln work toward domestic vats, braziers, and tiles), and Pia/Lorn lack authority to bind Hearthmere to a major forward production pact without leader consent. This overrides character agency and leadership power limits.", "player_id": "GM" }, { "message": "Fact fact-measure-valley-commons-victory-turn6 contains charter source terminology ('sustained voluntary investment' from the Victory rules), meta-game turn calendar counters ('six consecutive months'), and omniscient GM evaluation ('achieved permanent stability and mutual prosperity'). Player-visible facts must contain only in-world consequences and no omniscient appraisal or rulebook source text.", "player_id": "GM" }, { "message": "Leader-barleybank is credited with DIRECT_OBSERVATION (empty propagation path) for fact-reedhaven-river-convoy-turn6, but Barleybank's leader was in Barleybank and could not directly observe Garr and Fara's landing operations downriver at Reedhaven or the full transit to Hearthmere; this requires propagation via returning supercargoes.", "player_id": "player1" }, { "message": "Fact fact-reedhaven-hearthmere-pact-turn6 discloses a completed binding agreement allocating 20-25 jars, which was only a proposal from Player 2 and was neither authorized nor agreed to by Hearthmere.", "player_id": "player2" }, { "message": "Leader-hearthmere is credited with DIRECT_OBSERVATION (empty propagation path) for fact-measure-house-harvest-sync-turn6 and fact-reedhaven-hearthmere-pact-turn6 at Measure House, despite Hearthwarden remaining in Hearthmere and sending Pia as witness. Knowledge of Measure House events must be REPORTED via Pia.", "player_id": "player3" }, { "message": "Fact fact-reedhaven-hearthmere-pact-turn6 binds Hearthmere to an unsubmitted, unauthorized jar production contract that conflicts with Hearthwarden's explicit orders for kiln cooling and domestic wares.", "player_id": "player3" }, { "message": "Leader-stonecross is credited with DIRECT_OBSERVATION (empty propagation path) for fact-measure-house-harvest-sync-turn6 at Measure House, despite Roadwarden remaining in Stonecross to inspect the reference vault and sending Willa as representative. Knowledge of Measure House events must be REPORTED via Willa.", "player_id": "player4" } ], "rationale": "The proposed adjudication successfully resolves the primary harvest and logistics operations, but fails review due to two major causal/rule issues and several epistemic propagation defects. First, GM Decision T006-D02 approves a completed, binding pact (and obligation OBL-reedhaven-hearthmere-storage-jars) committing Hearthmere to deliver 20-25 ceramic jars to Reedhaven based solely on Player 2's proposal, violating character agency and leadership boundaries because Player 3 never authorized this trade and explicitly ordered kilns dedicated to domestic wares. Second, player-facing fact fact-measure-valley-commons-victory-turn6 leaks charter rule terminology ('sustained voluntary investment'), meta calendar references ('six consecutive months'), and omniscient GM victory evaluations rather than reporting in-world consequences. Finally, leader-hearthmere and leader-stonecross were erroneously assigned DIRECT_OBSERVATION for assembly events at Measure House that were attended only by their appointed witnesses (Pia and Willa), and leader-barleybank was assigned DIRECT_OBSERVATION for Reedhaven's downriver landing management." } }