accepted

{
  "approved": false,
  "fact_id": "fact-restitution-discharge-turn4",
  "player_id": "player1",
  "rationale": "Barleybank's delegation and leadership remained at Barleybank during Month 4, awaiting the arrival of river barges. While Barleybank legitimately received the certified transfer chits and confirmation from Measure House, it did not directly observe the assembly proceedings or Reedhaven's standard grain exchange at Measure House. The disclosure inappropriately attributes source_type DIRECT_OBSERVATION and epistemic_status OBSERVED rather than REPORTED."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-jar-transport-intake-turn4",
  "player_id": "player1",
  "rationale": "Barleybank landing crews and leadership directly executed the padded-sled landing, intake inspection alongside Reedhaven's barge master, and staging of all thirty jars onto straw-cushioned timber dunnage in the communal storehouse. Direct observation and confirmed confidence are fully justified."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-barleybank-domestic-turn4",
  "player_id": "player1",
  "rationale": "Directly observed internal Barleybank domestic operations: Ada's rationing and foraging sweeps, Cora's crop transects, and Bran's drainage channel maintenance. Fully evidenced by player directives and local capacity."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-restitution-discharge-turn4",
  "player_id": "player2",
  "rationale": "Reedhaven's delegation led by Jora was physically present at Measure House for the scheduled Early Summer trade, personally witnessing the delivery of Hearthmere's thirty jars, the striking of the winter relief deficit, and the execution of their own grain exchange under joint supervision. Epistemic status OBSERVED is fully supported."
}

{
  "approved": false,
  "fact_id": "fact-jar-transport-intake-turn4",
  "player_id": "player2",
  "rationale": "While Reedhaven boat crews operated the river barges, landed at Barleybank, and received delivery chits, the statement includes Barleybank's private domestic storehouse arrangements (staging onto straw-cushioned timber dunnage in the communal storehouse) that Reedhaven boatmen did not inspect or observe. Internal storehouse construction details should not be disclosed to Reedhaven."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-reedhaven-domestic-turn4",
  "player_id": "player2",
  "rationale": "Directly observed internal Reedhaven domestic operations: Hana's split weaving lines, Ivo's comparative ceramic-vs-reed storage trials, and wetland fishing/rhizome foraging. Fully evidenced by submission orders."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-restitution-discharge-turn4",
  "player_id": "player3",
  "rationale": "Hearthmere's delegation led by Pia personally transported the thirty certified jars to Measure House, delivered them into joint custody, and witnessed Belen, Sella, and Oren strike the winter relief deficit from the central ledger. Direct observation is fully justified."
}

{
  "approved": false,
  "fact_id": "fact-jar-transport-intake-turn4",
  "player_id": "player3",
  "rationale": "Hearthmere was not involved in river transit or downstream reception. While Hearthmere might eventually learn via trade partners that the jars arrived safely, this statement leaks private domestic arrangements inside Barleybank's communal storehouse (straw-cushioned timber dunnage, padded sled transfer) across settlement lines without an in-world causal observation path."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-hearthmere-domestic-turn4",
  "player_id": "player3",
  "rationale": "Directly observed internal Hearthmere operations: Kira and Lorn's continuous kiln firing cycles, Noll's timber seasoning, and Mela's integration of the eighteen households with midday heat-safety pauses. Supported by submission evidence."
}

{
  "approved": false,
  "fact_id": "fact-restitution-discharge-turn4",
  "player_id": "player4",
  "rationale": "Stonecross's delegation returned home to the uplands at the close of Month 3 and had no representatives at Measure House during Month 4. The knowledge entry records source_type PROPAGATED via Belen, yet the disclosure envelope assigns epistemic_status OBSERVED. Propagated news cannot grant direct observation; epistemic status must be REPORTED."
}

{
  "approved": false,
  "fact_id": "fact-jar-transport-intake-turn4",
  "player_id": "player4",
  "rationale": "Stonecross is situated in the northeast uplands and had no presence along the river or at Barleybank. The disclosure leaks private Barleybank storehouse preparations (straw-cushioned timber dunnage) and river transit outcomes without any causal carrier or observer. Additionally, assigning epistemic_status OBSERVED alongside source_type PROPAGATED via exchange-witnesses is internally contradictory and causally unsupported."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-waystation-masonry-turn4",
  "player_id": "player4",
  "rationale": "Directly observed internal Stonecross operations: Ressa vaulting the reference stone under intact multi-clan seals, Una and Tovin elevating retaining wall masonry to breastwork height under ox rest cycles, and staffing the roadside shelter waystation. Fully evidenced by submission orders."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-domestic-turn4",
  "player_id": "player4",
  "rationale": "Directly observed internal Stonecross subsistence routines: terrace crop weeding, Tovin dressing portable quern-stones, and the community celebratory meal. Fully evidenced by submission orders."
}

{
  "message": "Decision T004-D02 scopes fact-jar-transport-intake-turn4 as PUBLIC, improperly merging river transit and landing delivery with Barleybank's private domestic storehouse operations (straw-cushioned timber dunnage in the communal storehouse). This creates an information leak of Barleybank's private storehouse preparations to Hearthmere and Stonecross. The GM should separate the public transit/exchange outcome from Barleybank's private domestic storage arrangements.",
  "player_id": "GM"
}

{
  "message": "Decision T004-D03 bundles the operational status of the roadside shelter waystation (an approved public regional commitment under Turn 3 accords) exclusively into fact-stonecross-waystation-masonry-turn4, which is visible only to Player 4. While private vaulting and masonry belong in a player-scoped fact, the activation of the regional roadside waystation for valley travelers lacks representation in a player-visible fact for regional trading partners.",
  "player_id": "GM"
}

{
  "message": "Disclosure fact-jar-transport-intake-turn4 cannot be approved for player4: Stonecross has no observers on the river or at Barleybank, and cannot observe Barleybank's internal storehouse dunnage. Furthermore, assigning epistemic_status OBSERVED while citing source_type PROPAGATED via exchange-witnesses is epistemically and causally contradictory.",
  "player_id": "player4"
}

{
  "message": "Disclosure fact-restitution-discharge-turn4 cannot be approved as OBSERVED for player4: Stonecross returned to the uplands in Month 3 and was absent from Measure House during Month 4. Notice received via Belen must be classified as REPORTED rather than OBSERVED.",
  "player_id": "player4"
}

{
  "message": "Disclosure fact-jar-transport-intake-turn4 cannot be approved for player3: Hearthmere has no observers or causal path to know the internal storehouse staging arrangements (straw-cushioned timber dunnage) constructed inside Barleybank's communal storehouse.",
  "player_id": "player3"
}

{
  "message": "Disclosure fact-jar-transport-intake-turn4 includes internal storehouse construction details (straw-cushioned timber dunnage inside Barleybank's communal storehouse) that Reedhaven boatmen did not inspect or observe at the landing.",
  "player_id": "player2"
}

{
  "message": "Disclosure fact-restitution-discharge-turn4 cannot be approved as DIRECT_OBSERVATION / OBSERVED for player1: Barleybank's leadership and witnesses remained at Barleybank during Month 4. Confirmation of the Measure House ledger discharge was received through delivery chits and messages, requiring epistemic_status REPORTED.",
  "player_id": "player1"
}