accepted

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-restitution-discharge-turn4",
  "player_id": "player1",
  "rationale": "Barleybank receives reported confirmation of the Measure House restitution discharge and scheduled exchange via Reedhaven's boatmen and Jora communicating with Esme upon arrival at Barleybank landing."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-jar-river-transit-turn4",
  "player_id": "player1",
  "rationale": "Barleybank landing crews under Dain and storekeepers Esme and Ada directly observed the arrival of Reedhaven's cargo boats, inspected the ceramic jars on padded sleds, and issued safe delivery chits."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-barleybank-jar-staging-turn4",
  "player_id": "player1",
  "rationale": "Directly observed within Barleybank, where Dain constructed timber cradles and straw-cushioned dunnage in the communal storehouse to stage the thirty intact jars."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-roadside-waystation-turn4",
  "player_id": "player1",
  "rationale": "Barleybank learns of the operational Stonecross roadside shelter through traveling regional messengers and communication from Stonecross witness Willa to Esme."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-barleybank-domestic-turn4",
  "player_id": "player1",
  "rationale": "Directly observed within Barleybank: Ada enforced hungry-gap rationing and gathering sweeps, Cora conducted crop sampling transects, and Bran maintained drainage channels."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-restitution-discharge-turn4",
  "player_id": "player2",
  "rationale": "Reedhaven witness Jora attended Measure House in person, directly observing the delivery of thirty jars, the striking of the winter deficit, and the execution of Reedhaven's scheduled grain exchange."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-jar-river-transit-turn4",
  "player_id": "player2",
  "rationale": "Reedhaven boat crews directly conducted and observed the river transport of the ceramic jars, navigated the reed boats with impact baffles, and received delivery chits at Barleybank landing."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-roadside-waystation-turn4",
  "player_id": "player2",
  "rationale": "Reedhaven learned of the active upland waystation via Willa's communication to Jora at Measure House and reports from traveling trade parties."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-reedhaven-domestic-turn4",
  "player_id": "player2",
  "rationale": "Directly observed within Reedhaven: Hana organized basketry lines for hampers and jar sleeves, while Ivo managed grain intake, comparative jar storage tests, and wetland foraging."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-restitution-discharge-turn4",
  "player_id": "player3",
  "rationale": "Hearthmere witness Pia directly attended Measure House, delivering the thirty standardized jars into joint custody and witnessing the formal ledger discharge alongside Belen, Sella, and Oren."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-jar-river-transit-turn4",
  "player_id": "player3",
  "rationale": "Hearthmere receives reported confirmation via Reedhaven's delegation (Jora to Pia) confirming that the crated, sleeved ceramic jars completed river transit safely and secured delivery chits at Barleybank."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-roadside-waystation-turn4",
  "player_id": "player3",
  "rationale": "Hearthmere learned of the active Stonecross roadside waystation through Willa's report to Pia at Measure House and traveling messengers along the valley road."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-hearthmere-domestic-turn4",
  "player_id": "player3",
  "rationale": "Directly observed within Hearthmere: Kira and Lorn ran continuous kiln firings, Noll managed drying fuel and fire breaks, and Mela integrated the eighteen households with midday heat breaks."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-restitution-discharge-turn4",
  "player_id": "player4",
  "rationale": "Stonecross receives reported confirmation of the Measure House assembly and ledger discharge through senior witness Belen's routine administrative communication to Stonecross."
}

{
  "approved": false,
  "fact_id": "fact-jar-river-transit-turn4",
  "player_id": "player4",
  "rationale": "Stonecross is located upland and played no role in river freight or Barleybank landing operations. No Stonecross witness observed the boat transport, sled unloading, or issuance of delivery chits at Barleybank, no communication path exists in Month 4, and the knowledge record is empty. Disclosing this localized downriver event to player4 with OBSERVED status is causally ungrounded."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-roadside-waystation-turn4",
  "player_id": "player4",
  "rationale": "Directly observed within Stonecross: the community staffed the roadside shelter on rotating two-person watches, providing hearth firewood, spring water, bedding, and transit logging."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-masonry-vault-turn4",
  "player_id": "player4",
  "rationale": "Directly observed within Stonecross: Ressa vaulted the reference stone in the upland storehouse, and Una and Tovin advanced retaining wall masonry to breastwork height under ox pacing rules."
}

{
  "approved": true,
  "fact_id": "fact-stonecross-domestic-turn4",
  "player_id": "player4",
  "rationale": "Directly observed within Stonecross: terrace crops were weeded and check-dams reinforced, Tovin directed quarrying toward portable querns and whetstones, and the settlement held a communal dinner."
}

{
  "message": "Disclosure of fact-jar-river-transit-turn4 to player4 is unsupported: Stonecross characters did not observe downriver barge transport or Barleybank landing intake, and no knowledge propagation path exists.",
  "player_id": "player4"
}

{
  "message": "Decision T004-D02 incorrectly assigned PUBLIC visibility scope to fact-jar-river-transit-turn4. The river transport and landing inspection details are local to Reedhaven and Barleybank (and reported to Hearthmere), with no causal carrier to Stonecross in Month 4. Visibility should be restricted to PLAYERS [player1, player2, player3].",
  "player_id": "GM"
}